Saturday, June 4, 2011

What a "NO" vote means to you, North Carolina women.......


This coming week, the legislative committee in Raleigh will vote on whether or not the state should develop a licensing process for Certified Professional Midwives. This process will cost the state nothing....yes, you read correctly, FREE! The cost will be absorbed by the midwives applying for the license. Not only does it not cost the state, but the normalization of home birth will in all probability save our state money. In this time of tragic economics, why would our representatives vote against something that is win-win for NC? I think you should ask them.

I know what some who are unfamiliar with home birth and the skill level of Certified Professional Midwives are thinking. Have babies at home? What? Isn't that dangerous? What if there is an emergency? I don't blame you for asking these questions. If the only thing you know about home birth is from reading the paper, then you are probably horrified. Articles devoid of fact and chock full of ignorant opinion are rampant. Haywood Brown is one of those writers and he demonstrates his editorial ability in this article: http://heraldsun.com/view/full_story/13326332/article-N-C--should-not-li

The fact is that the safety of home birth has been proven. This makes some people fuming mad. Many obstetricians are offended at the thought that anyone besides one of their own could deliver a healthy baby to a healthy mother. They choose to believe the untruths that suit their purposes and ramble on about unskilled attendants and the "what ifs" as if a home birth midwife walks into a birth with some boiled water and a prayer. The truth is that most obstetricians have no idea what the education of a Certified Professional Midwife entails. They haven't the first clue at the professionalism and precision with which a home birth with a CPM is handled. I have heard comments from physicians and other hospital staff such as, "Oh, so they(CPM's) are certified in neonatal resuscitation?" or "Oh, so they do carry instruments." This is an insult to birthing women...that their physicians would offer such opinions on something they know so little about.



But understand that not all physicians feel that way. Here locally, Dr. Henry Dorn of High Point, NC, believes in the skill of midwives and the right of the woman to choose her place of birth. Read about his views here: http://www.theunnecesarean.com/blog/2010/12/10/an-alternative-obgyn-birth-plan.html
Of course, doctors like him don't support these choices without paying a price. As a doula, I watch other physicians blackball and bully these doctors...refusing to support them if they are ever sued and causing attitudes of tension and indignation between the nurses in the hospitals where they practice.

A vote of "no" in the legislative committee will support this behavior. It will support the notion that women are a species to be controlled and managed. It will support the ideology that pregnant women are too ignorant to educate themselves about pregnancy and birth and need to be led rather than have an active voice in their care. It will say that the practice of liability based medical decisions and interventions should continue whether or not it is best for the patient. It doesn't matter that it costs our state money and lives(check out NC's maternal and infant mortality). It doesn't matter that our cesarean rate is more than double the the World Health Organization's recommended 15%.

Many of my clients....and I do mean MANY....are currently driving over 45 miles to seek out the care that they want for their pregnancy and birth. Many are willing to take their dollars into our bordering states that have realized their value and they are birthing there.

Yet doctors still claim that mothers and babies will start dying all around us if CPM's are legalized. Yet, none of them can explain why this is not happening in Virginia, South Carolina and Tennessee where CPM's practice legally. None of them can explain why North Carolina's maternal and infant mortality are not improving. None of them can explain why babies and mothers still die in the hospital where all of the life saving equipment that they claim is absolutely necessary is available and at an arms reach. A vote of "no" will say to NC women that your only choice is the hospital where they are not achieving the same standard that they are setting for midwives, but that is ok because they have "MD" behind their name.

Yes, mothers and babies die or are injured during birth. It doesn't happen often, but it does happen. Many times, it is beyond the control of any person, machine or intervention. Life happens....death happens. This will always be. A vote of "yes" or "no" will never change that.

But a vote of "no" will say that our system doesn't need to change or improve. It will say that what we have now is satisfactory even though statistics show that NC is not anywhere near the safest place in the US to give birth. It will say to all women, whether they birth at home or the hospital, that it is just not worth raising the standard for you. Because you see, the availability of a more appealing form of care will force doctors to change their ways if they want to keep their business. They may actually have to admit that pregnancy is not a disease and that women are valuable and smart enough in our society to be informed and have a say in their pregnancy and birth. What a radical concept.

I have attended over 100 births as a doula. No matter what anyone says, I see first hand how all of this plays out in both hospital and home. Women who want normal birth have few options that are stress free and don't involve arguing and being scolded by your physician. And little by little, women are beginning to question.....to study.....to empower themselves and realize that they are capable of normal birth. They see through the lies of people like out of work physician, Dr. Amy Tuteur who not only decries natural birth, but taunts and insults the women who want it. Mothers are realizing that this is contributing to the devaluing of women in our society and they refuse that for themselves and for their own daughters. On a local level, we listen to the angry rants of people like Tara Servatius, formerly of WBT talk radio, who are beyond accepting fact and seem to enjoy spewing fiction to the public just to make this group of women who would choose empowered birth look selfish and reckless. Women read Haywood Brown's opinion and realize that he and others like him have no desire to see them be treated better or to be kept safer. Their desires are rooted in their own egos and agendas. A vote of "no" supports those egos and agendas and says that the value of women is expendable.

Lastly, a vote of "no" says to North Carolina women that your voice is small and unimportant. North Carolina women have driven hours with children in tow to stand on the lawn en masse in Raleigh. They write, they call, they carry signs. They have rallied. They are not asking for the right to birth at home. This IS their right. They are simply asking for the access to an accountable, licensed professional to be there to help facilitate a safe birth.

Will NC say no to safety? Will NC say that it does not value its women? Will NC say that the rich physicians of the medical society and ACOG are the only people qualified to facilitate birth in NC? Will NC FORCE all women into the hospitals where they are not making the grade?

Next week, when the committee votes....these questions will be answered with a very simple "yes" or "no." So pay attention, NC women. Your worth is about to be determined.

Wednesday, March 30, 2011

Why did I do it?????



This week on my Facebook page I posted about an experience I had with a client who wanted to have a vaginal birth after two previous cesareans(VBA2C). My client was bullied by a doctor who was on staff, but not her personal physician. She was lectured like a child and told that because of her refusal to submit to a third cesarean, all women who desired a VBAC at Lake Norman Regional Hospital were now in danger of losing that opportunity. It was an ugly scene that shocked and saddened me. It haunted me. Throughout the day I kept hearing the tone of Dr. Grant Miller's voice. I kept seeing the expression on his face along with his defensive body language. The words he had spoken caused a painful ringing in my ears.

He is not the first to have this attitude and he certainly won't be the last. But it was such an extreme experience for me as a doula having attended almost 100 births in my career, that I could not help but write about it and make others aware. Believe me, I knew what I was in for. While some would be fully supportive, I knew there would be some who would oppose what I had done.

So why did I do it? Simple. Because I need to be able to sleep at night. To sweep that situation under the rug and move on was not an option for me. I believe in the women I support. I believe in birth. That is why I work in this field.

I was that woman not too long ago. My second child was born by cesarean after a failed induction for a big baby(who ended up being 7lbs 7oz). My body simply wasn't ready to have a baby. I lamented this for years. Now, I know what many would say. I should just have been happy to have a healthy baby. I should have focused less on how the baby got here and focused more on the fact that he was here. Yes, I heard all those things. I still hear those things said to my clients at times. Do people have any idea how much it hurts to hear that your deepest desires and feelings are selfish and invalid? Do you think that all those years I didn't LONG to be at peace with my birth? Let me tell you that I DID. I wanted more than anything to be able to just move past it and let it go. But I couldn't. It isn't natural for a woman not to care about such things. The pain of being separated from my baby in those first few hours because of side effects from my anesthesia was devastating. Those moments were critical. I can never get them back! How dare anyone suggest that I am selfish for wishing I had made different decisions or that things had happened differently. My VBAC 10 years later was one of the most healing experiences in my life. I felt redeemed and renewed. Many doctors and even some nurses think that is ridiculous.......that it shouldn't matter that much. That such emotions should not be tied to the birth process. I am here to tell you that they are and that it is completely normal and natural. To feel differently would require me to turn off a part of myself that is crucial to birthing and mothering....my instincts.

As a doula, I never really know what to expect. Some doctors and nurses welcome my presence and see me as an asset to the patient experience. Some roll their eyes at me and see me as some kind of natural birth nazi who tortures women for the sake of unmedicated birth. Some are in the middle and wait to decide whether they like me or not by how compliant my client is to their wishes. I only have so much control over their perceptions of me.

However, it was ingrained in my being the moment I accepted the calling to go into the birth field that I would advocate for these women.

I realize the risks. I knew when I wrote the note that I could receive some backlash. I knew it would cost me. If approached by anyone for doula services who lists Lake Norman Ob/Gyn as their provider, I will have to refer them on to another doula for their own sake. I will have to let them know that my presence amongst their doctors could actually hurt them more than help them. If money were my concern, I certainly would have remained quietly oppositional.

I also realize that there is a time and a place for medical intervention. I do not believe that every single woman should have a baby at home with a midwife. I do not believe that every woman should have an unmedicated birth. I do not believe that every cesarean is unecessary. Medical intervention can be very necessary and lifesaving and is needed when complications arise. I am thankful that hospitals and obstetrician/surgeons are available when these needs arise. I am also unopposed to women who want medical interventions. If they have made an informed decision to have an epidural for pain or to have a medically unecessary induction, then I support that.

And let me be clear - I am not saying that Dr. Miller is a bad doctor. I saw comments defending what he did.....testimonies from women he has helped. They adore him enough to excuse his bad behavior and that is most certainly their perogative to do so. But in my world, being good to a million women doesn't excuse violating one.

I am not calling for a crucifixion of Dr. Miller, or a lynching at Lake Norman. I am simply wanting them to be aware of their consumers opinions. Yes, the patients are the consumers. They pay for the services they receive. Their voices deserve to be heard. We cannot allow birthing women to be violated. There are respectful ways to approach someone when hospital policy does not support what they want. Interpersonal skills can be learned by anyone and are very useful in professional dealings and should be used when dealing with sensitive situations. But above all, when a patient has been informed of risks, benefits and rules and they still don't want to be cut open, there needs to be a place of respect for that. No one expected Dr. Miller's blessing in that moment, but we did expect the situation to be handled respectfully and in a way that upholds the dignity of the patient. This is a MINIMAL standard to uphold.

Women who desire an intervention free birth are not just crunchy granolas who want to light incense and drum the baby out. It isn't about having a candlelit experience with Gregorian Chanting in the background. Our desires are for our lives and the health of our babies. Our desires go deep to our core and are rooted in intelligence and research. We have not dismissed the value of medicine, but we have not deified it either. We are well aware that more women die in childbirth right now than should and that the reason for this is the amount of cesareans that happen every day in this country. We want obstetrical care to be women centered instead of liabilty centered or physician centered. For those who want the epidural and a martini when they walk in the door, we say let them. But for those who do not, we say, RESPECT THEM!

Friday, February 11, 2011

The plea of the woman desiring natural birth in the hospital.....


Dear Doctor, L&D nurse and other hospital personel.....

Thank you for taking care of me during my labor and delivery. I wanted to communicate this information to you before I enter your establishment so that you may better serve me while I am there. All the signs on the walls say that this hospital's top concern is patient safety AND satisfaction. I am trusting that you as an individual are concerned about that also.

I have been pregnant for 9 long months. I am excited, scared and overwhelmed all at the same time. When I come in the door, please take that into consideration. I realize that I may be the fourth person you've taken care of today, but I really want a good relationship with you from the start.

This may be my first baby. I may have had a traumatic birth experience in the past. I could be a high need personality or extremely laid back. Either way, I will want your help and your support. I realize that when I come in, it is your job to get me through the admissions process which involves multiple questions. Please don't be upset if I wave at you to give me a moment or if my answers are short and curt. I am trying to work with my body and focus on my labor. I cannot possibly remember when I had my last tetanus shot, but I realize you have to ask and I will do my best to answer you when I can breathe. I will try to sign the forms, but I may have questions and they may just have to wait.

I want an natural birth. You may read my birth plan and chalk me up to one of the many women who come in saying this and end up getting the epidural anyway. I may be that woman, but please give me the benefit of the doubt. My desires for birth are extremely important. I don't get to do this day over.

I realize that there are medications available for pain and they are given to women all the time. I know that you see women use them frequently without issue, but I have researched the risks and the benefits and have determined that I will not use them unless the benefit outweighs the risk at that particular time. Do not assume I am trying to be a hero or trying to prove something to myself or others. I have deep convictions about why feeling the pain is worth it for myself and for my baby. If this is not a decision you made for yourself at your own birth, don't assume that you understand my mindset. I don't expect you to. I only ask that you respect what I am doing and be supportive.

I realize that every decision that is made affects my memory of this experience forever. I also realize that each intervention I agree to could and probably will lead to another. I will not take any decision lightly so please don't be offended when I ask for time to talk to my birth team or to just take in the information that I have been given. I am very aware that birth is unpredictable and that unexpected things can and do happen. I am open to changes in my birth plan. All I ask is that you present my options to me as the consumer and decision-maker. I do not want to be told what I am allowed to do and not allowed to do. At the end of the day, I will be paying the bill for this experience so just as you would not walk into a room full of your superiors and present them with your plan for their day, please don't do that to me. If you present my options to me in the spirit of informed consent, there should be no communication issues, and I am more likely to trust your judgement.

I do care about the health of myself and my baby. I would never want to jeopardize either. So when you come in to tell me that one or the other looks to be compromised, please be ready to present me with some data. Don't assume that I am being non-compliant when I question your recommendations. Simply explain to me clearly what the risks of the situation are and give me evidence based facts.

Speaking of evidence based, please don't act like I am a hippy earth mother just because I want to do things that ARE evidence based such as delayed cord clamping, eating and drinking freely while in labor, pushing in a position other than on my back, intermittent(not constant) fetal monitoring, no separation of mother and baby and skin to skin contact immediately. I realize you see a lot of tragic things, but unless there is a reason to assume my pregnancy and labor is not normal, I am assuming it is. Please support me in that. If you don't believe in evidence based practices, be ready to explain to me why that is. I have a right to know.

I may have some other members of my birth team besides my husband/partner. I may have a doula. I realize all doulas are different. You may have had a negative experience with one. But this is my birth and it is my right to have her there. I ask that you treat her with respect and if there is any issue with her behavior, please discuss that with me as I am paying for her services the same as I am paying for yours. Don't assume that my decisions have been influenced by her. The mere fact that I hired her should be a clue that I am a person who has done more than the average amount of research about birth. Since births where doulas are present have been shown to have better outcomes for mothers, I would think you would be completely on board. To my nurse, I have asked her to talk me out of pain medication. She has seen multiple women labor and knows that at some point I will probably ask for it. Do not assume she is torturing me. She and I have formed a relationship over the course of my pregnancy and I trust her. I have just met you and you do not know my deepest desires for this day. But she does. Please work together with her as part of MY team.

Lastly, if my birth plan changes and I end up with an intervention or a situation that I clearly did not want, acknowledge my disappointment. Validate my grief. Do not try to make me feel better by pointing out that I am safe and healthy and so is my baby. Of course, I am thankful for that. But my experience was important too, and it is normal to feel some grief over the loss of the birth I had hoped for. If you would just be sensitive to my feelings and support my process, then I will work through it much easier. Your acknowledgement of my disappointment will help me feel like I did all the right things and that you truly cared about my desires. I will be less likely to question myself and question my care providers if they do not dismiss my concerns. I may need to talk about the moments that my plan took a turn. I may need more details after the fact. Please give me that information. It is helpful to me as I move forward into motherhood. It helps me transition and adjust to the unpredictable role of "mom". I will feel more confident when you treat me with the utmost respect.

Thank you for hearing me. I hope that my birth will be everything I want it to be. I hope that you want that for me. I am on a journey, and you have been asked to come alongside me. Wherever that journey leads, I hope that we all walk away with a sense of satisfaction and of course, a healthy mom and baby.

Wednesday, December 29, 2010

Reviving yourself......and your blog.....


My blogging skills have gone into hibernation and I will once again attempt to revive them for the upcoming year. My time seems to be swept away by births, phone calls and the constant studying that I must to in order to sit for my midwifery exam in 2011. Oh, and did I mention being a wife and mother too? However, writing has always been a passion of mine and it is so important never to let those things you are passionate about get lost in your responsibilities.

So, my other thoughts for the new year.......be a voice for birthing women. This year I would like to be involved in some activities that bring awareness to the importance of a woman's birth experience. I am thinking, perhaps, of collaborating with some other birth professionals to hold some community activities that would accomplish this. Stay tuned for more on that!

I will begin teaching prenatal yoga on a regular basis in January at Charlotte Family Yoga Center. I am very excited about this. Yoga is an excellent way to learn to listen to and work with your body. These are important skills for the laboring woman to have regardless of whether she intends to utilize pain medication, or have an unmedicated birth. Yoga helps with the common discomforts of pregnancy as well by strengthening the lower back, the pelvic floor, the shoulders and other areas of the body that typcially ache and ail while we are pregnant. I am excited about teaching yoga again and sharing this wonderful form of exercise with expecting moms.

Twenty eleven is looking to be an awesome year. I will be watching quite a few women whom I have already assisted deliver again! I can't believe I've been doing this long enough for that to be happening. It is so exciting and such an honor! I'm looking forward with anticipation and curiosity. Life is good. MY life is awesome!

Sunday, January 24, 2010

The Nuances of Dilation....


On my local mommy message board, there is much talk about dilation and effacement. Around here, doctors start checking you at 36 weeks. Why? Who knows. The information is not beneficial to anyone from what I can see. It seems to only serve to make the mom anxious.

There are women who actually believe that they have "undilated"....meaning they were told they were a certain number of cm's, and then at the next visit told they were less. So just for my own peace of mind, I explain the art of checking dilation from my perspective.

When I first began checking dilation, one of my mentor midwives showed me how to get a good feel for the cervix, then withdraw your fingers and actually check on a tape measure to see how many centimeters it was. Now this is still tricky as you must visualize in your head how far apart your fingers are since you can't see them. And you can't withdraw your two fingers and keep them apart as that would be uncomfortable for the mother. So you can get my drift here that this is NOT an exact science.

Now, when a cervix is almost closed, or one fingertip....that is usually 1cm. But as you get into 2-7cm....it is very tricky. And everyone is a little different. Sometimes a practitioner will stretch the cervix a bit and be generous with their cm's, whereas my midwife wants to know the dilation without any stretching. So if you are checked by two people, one who interprets with a stretch and one who doesn't, you may get two very different results. Also, since perception plays such a big role, this can cause discrepancy between two different cervical exams. My vision in my head of how far apart my fingers are may be innacurate by a cm or so. This is why I always call a cervix about 1cm less that what I think it really is. I would rather underestimat than over...then have a devastated mom if someone else checks and she has appeared to "go backwards."

There is usually no question at 8, 9, and 10cm as these are not hard to assess. But no one ever thinks to ask their nurse how long they have been checking cervixes. You may have the newest nurse on the L&D floor and she may not have really gotten adept at cervical checks yet. She has to feel as insecure as I did those first few times. And out of those first few times, I was off a bit according to my midwife.

It is an art....not a science. And just when I think I have mastered it after a year of working in the birth biz, I will check a cervix that makes me go, "huh?" becuase it is so puzzling.

So the fact is, if your doctor or nurse says you're 8, 9 or 10cm..do the happy dance and get ready to push out a baby. If its somewhere between 2 and 7...take it with a grain of salt, keep breathing and know that the baby will come. And those routine checks at the dr's office.....a simple no thank you will keep you from letting those numbers transform in your brain to crazy thoughts such as, "This baby is never going to come!" or "I'm 3cm, I will go into labor tonight!" only to go another week.

Monday, December 14, 2009

Will informed consent become extinct???

Recently I attended a birth where the doctor told my client that studies have proven that women and babies have better outcomes when we "manage" labor. He cited "the Ireland Study" which at the time I had never heard of. There was a good reason for that. It was done before I was born. I am 38. That's been a while. I can't think of many studies that were done that many years ago that still hold water today.

Here is what we do know. Our cesarean rate as a nation is at an all time high - curently 31.8% as of 2007. This was a 48% rise from 1996. In 1970, the national cesarean rate was 6%. See date from fellow blogger:


With stats like that, how dare a doctor reference an outdated study to try to convince my client that she needs pitocin so that she will have her baby faster. Those statistics are a frightening look at what managing labor can do.

Most women never question what their doctor suggests. Many women go their entire lives thinking that they would have never gone into labor if they hadn't been induced because they were induced with all of their children at 41 weeks. One thing that statistically we do know....no one stays pregnant forever. Many women believe that it's a good thing that they had that cesarean for failure to progress because when the baby was born, he/she had a cord wrapped around their neck (maybe even twice). Cords are gently unwrapped from around baby's necks(during homebirths)the majority of the time, I would say. It is not an uncommon occurence.

Women are believing a lie that they are powerless in their birth process. They are being taught by providers that listening to their instincts is reckless and instead, they should completely trust the information from their doctor. Little do they know that it is the insurance companies that have more control over a doctors decisions and protocols. Dr's are threatened on a daily basis with unseen increase in their malpractice insurance if they don't follow the game plan. As long as no harm is done right?? Well, no visible harm. Sometimes, the harm of a interventive labor is to the woman's psychological well being. But hey, most lawsuits for that aren't successful, so it's as good of a risk as any. The doctor's malpractice insurance remains affordable.....and women everwhere don't understand why they feel they lost control of their whole experience? Informing and empowering????? I think not.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Enlightenment continues......

My current reading for my midwifery study unit is Easing Labor Pain by Adrienne Leiberman. I must say, the first few chapters were dry as a bone. Granted, I do have an older edition and some of the information is dated, but still dry nonetheless. However, as you get past the 4th or 5th chapter, I found the book to be very informative. Here are some excerpts I found important:

In Chapter 6, titled "You are what you eat", I found wonderful nutritional advice. For instance, Adelle Davis, a respected nutritionist, recommends calcium supplementation at the beginning of labor. The premise is that calcium eases muscle cramps....thereby making uterine contractions less painful, but not less effective. This is not studied and documented, but I find it to be logical. And besides, what can it hurt to take a little extra calcium when your contractions get going. So have a tall glass of whole milk and take a nice cal-mag supplement at the get go and see what happens!

In chapter 17, "Hospital Routines: Is the pain worth the gain?", Lieberman writes,
"Each form of intervention carries with it certain risks, which are worth accepting in high risk situations where the benefits may outweigh the drawbacks. However, in low-risk situations, advantages of intervention frequently do not exist. Then these interventions only add risk and discomfort wihtout providing any compensatory benefits."

I wish I could help every woman embrace this concept. All of the things that you are subjected to at the hospital - for the good of you and your baby - have not been proven to make your outcome better. Unless your risk level during pregnancy warrants constant monitoring, routine IV fluids or other things, they really aren't necessary. And my next point explains why this is.

Quote from the same chapter: "By 1985, indeed two thirds of this country's obstetricians had been sued for malpractice at least once. This medicolegal climate makes an obstetrician much more likely to intervene in the birth process. As one obstetrician said, 'I've never heard of a doctor being sued for doing a cesarean, but lots of doctors have been sued for not doing one.'"

This is the crux of the matter. Many of the things that women believe are just part of a safe and healthy pregnancy are simply tools to put on paper to thwart a lawsuit. We don't want to believe that. Birth is beautiful....babies are cute....doctors who deliver them are pro woman and baby, right? Doctors must practice defensively in a country that allows them to be put out of a career over one lawsuit. How do they know that you aren't the one who will end their career? It's better to strap you with the fetal monitor and make you uncomfortable enough to scream for the epidural rather than not have it on and take that 2% chance that something will happen to your baby unknowingly.

Women must educate themselves on the true facts and figures regarding all of these interventions. Know what really makes you safe. The safest thing for you and your baby during labor(as long as you have no major medical complications) is to be up and walking around - moving. Do this at home. The longer you are at the hospital, the more likely you are to become uncomfortable enough to need the epidural. As soon as you get that first intervention and become immobile, then the baby runs the risk of struggling to adapt. If that happens, you will find yourself in the operating room.

Easing Labor Pain is worth the read for the mom who wants to be informed. THe book is not anti-hospital or anti-doctor. It is not going to tell you that you should just have a homebirth(but I might...LOL). It is very conservative, yet factual. There is also some wonderful information on methods of relaxation and labor coping strategies.

Want an empowering hopspital birth? Know your stuff. Find a provider you can trust. Hire a doula. Trust in your body. Keep moving. Push in a position that feels natural. Make your wishes clear. Make sure anyone present at your birth is completely onboard with your philosophies. Don't run through the doors after your first contraction. And finally.....remember that your body and your baby know the drill. Just relax and respond.